On The Originals Season 3, Phoebe Tonkin’s character Hayley is caught between two men, both of whom she loves dearly. What’s it like to be caught between these two men? According to Tonkin, “it’s complicated.“ (That’s a total understatement.) Jackson, she says, “feels like home“ for Hayley, but Elijah? The chemistry between them is undeniable and everybody knows it.