At 75, Has NATO Outlived Its Use? | By James W. Carden
Original Article in The American Conservative:
Seventy-five years ago, on April 4, 1949, the foreign ministers of 12 European and North American countries convened in Washington and signed the North Atlantic Treaty establishing NATO.
With war raging in Eastern Europe and calls from a number of NATO allies to escalate that war, unpopular yet critical questions need to be addressed with regard to the alliance’s history, its continuation, and its expansion, as well as its ramifications for U.S. national security. Indeed, several articles of faith with regard to NATO’s successes and indispensability turn out to be, upon even cursory examination, highly questionable—if not entirely mistaken.
While criticism of the alliance is effectively verboten in today’s Washington, at the time of its founding, some eminent American foreign policy thinkers such as Walter Lippmann warned that “a great power like the United States gains no advantages and it loses prestige by offering, indeed, peddling, its alliances to all and sundry. An alliance should be hard diplomatic currency, valuable and hard to get.”
An argument could be made that by the end of its first decade, NATO was already obsolete. The great Hungarian-American historian John Lukacs has argued that, by the mid-1950s, the Soviets (post-Stalin, post-Beria) were beating a retreat from the center of Europe. In 1954–55, they agreed to, in Lukacs’s words, a “reciprocal withdrawal” in Austria, paving that way for that country’s Cold War neutrality. Within a year the Soviets relinquished their naval base in Finland (which henceforth was to also pursue neutral status—that is, until last year) and mended ties with Tito’s Yugoslavia. By Lukacs’s accounting, 1956 “was the turning point of the cold war. Perhaps even the end of it, if by ‘cold war’ means the direct prospect of an actual war between American and Russian armed forces in Europe.”
Read the rest of the article here (or keep watching):
1 view
8
4
7 years ago 00:04:23 65
Hawk 75 at Legends
8 years ago 00:01:57 11
75. Me At 24
9 years ago 01:16:53 37
75 at 75: Mark Strand & Joseph Brodsky reading Brodsky
13 years ago 00:04:13 61
75 Years at Brambletye (Edit)
8 months ago 07:02:42 1
China at 75: Changes Unseen in a Century
2 years ago 01:39:12 1
Apartheid at 75 - The Grayzone live
8 years ago 00:03:40 3
04 - ვია 75 “ზღვასთან“ 1982 via 75 “At the Seaside“
9 years ago 00:03:43 153
Dappy - At It (Tarzan ) [feat. Tulisa]
8 months ago 01:05:02 1
China at 75, Panel 2: Exposing Imperialist Propaganda
5 years ago 01:17:23 2
75 at 75: W. H. Auden: “Bucolics“ and “Horae Cononicae“
13 years ago 00:02:25 782
Roman Strakhov 3BLD 1: at MPEI Open 2012
8 months ago 00:49:33 1
China at 75, Panel 1: Opening session
10 years ago 00:05:29 53
UFP 75: This One Time At Flight Camp
6 years ago 00:00:51 3
Железнодорожный плуг КБР-75 на о.п. Янеда / Railway plough KBR-75 at Jäneda stop
3 years ago 00:03:55 26
Paul McCartney - Young Boy (at 75)
5 years ago 00:13:45 1
Thomas At 75 - A Trip Down Memory Line
6 years ago 00:01:14 28
Hyde at John Wolmer Speed Fest
14 years ago 00:02:35 52
75 More Costumes At DragonCon 2011 - With Chad Vader
13 years ago 00:00:53 126
Alfa 75 Burnouts at Centenario Alfa Romeo in Rho Milano
8 months ago 00:12:03 1
Critical Media Literacy (KJ Noh) China at 75, Panel 5
13 years ago 00:02:01 17
75 Costumes At Dragon Con (with Chad Vader)
14 years ago 00:01:52 30
Jaguar cx 75 concept at the Paris motorshow 2010 - auto express
8 months ago 01:22:29 1
China at 75, Panel 5: Hybrid War on China
10 years ago 00:02:16 93
SYND 7 5 71ARRESTS AT ANTI VIETNAM WAR DEMONSTRATION